War Crimes Tribunals: Response to Eric A. Posner
To the Editor:
Eric A. Posner's denunciation of both the International Court of Justice and the recently established International Criminal Court in The Hague ("All Justice, Too, Is Local," Op-Ed, Dec. 30) repudiates the highest ideals espoused by the United States during the Nuremberg war crimes trials. I take issue with his depiction of the records, purposes and powers of these tribunals. He does not note that every nation has the right to try its own citizens.
The prosecutor is subject to strict controls, including close supervision by Britain, Canada and a host of other nations that are being alienated by bellicose intimidation and demands for immunity for all Americans. Mr. Posner expresses fear of politicization, yet favors Security Council control of the court.
Only lawbreakers need fear the rule of law. Mr. Posner warns international organizations to "adapt to great power politics" or "wither on the vine." We may all "wither" if we continue the power politics that inevitably leads to war rather than law.
Benjamin B. Ferencz
Delray Beach, Fla., Dec. 30, 2004
The writer was a prosecutor at the Nuremberg war crimes trials
Please see my website under "Articles" and click on "Misguided Fears About the International Criminal Court." Then make up your own mind. If you agree, please free to disseminate this message. What kind of government do you want? Good luck!